News
Brazil pesticide tariff dispute exposes divisions within industry
Brazil’s efforts to increase import tariffs on agricultural pesticides have exposed growing divisions between domestic manufacturers, generic pesticide companies and agricultural organizations, as the government weighs measures that could affect input costs and the competitiveness of local production.
On Friday (Nov. 6), most of the organizations represented in the Ministry of Agriculture’s Agricultural Inputs Thematic Chamber rejected a proposal to raise import duties on four pesticide from zero to 8% or 10% for 12 months. The proposal, submitted by the Brazilian Association of Fine Chemicals, Biotechnology and Specialties Industries (Abifina), covers fipronil, ammonium glufosinate, tebuthiuron and triclopyr.
The meeting brought together 44 organizations. Opponents included the Brazilian Agriculture and Livestock Confederation (CNA), the Brazilian Soybean Producers Association (Aprosoja), the Brazilian Cotton Producers Association (Abrapa), the National Association of Crop Protection Companies (Aenda) and representatives of agricultural input distributors. Abifina and the National Union of Plant Protection Products Industry (Sindiveg) supported the increase.
The vote was advisory and does not change current tariffs. The Ministry of Agriculture is expected to consider the request at a meeting of the Foreign Trade Chamber’s Tariff Changes Committee (CAT) on Tuesday (Nov. 10). If there is no unanimous decision, the matter will be referred to the chamber’s Executive Management Committee (Gecex).
The debate reflects competing interests across Brazil’s crop protection market. Domestic manufacturers argue that high production costs and growing competition from imported products, particularly from China, are undermining local industry, investment and jobs. Agricultural organizations, however, warn that higher duties could increase farmers’ expenses at a time of tight margins and elevated debt levels.
Brazil imported approximately US$2.79 billion worth of pesticides between January and September, including US$1.36 billion from China, according to foreign trade figures cited by the sector. Chinese products therefore accounted for almost half of the country’s imports during the period.
Sindiveg has also submitted separate requests to raise import tariffs on a broader range of formulated fungicides, herbicides and insecticides to as much as 35%, the maximum rate consolidated by Brazil at the World Trade Organization. The products include formulations based on mancozeb, 2,4-D, azoxystrobin, tebuconazole and prothioconazole, as well as products containing bifenthrin and lambda-cyhalothrin. Some requests seek to remove products from Brazil’s List of Exceptions to the Common External Tariff, under which certain imports currently benefit from reduced or zero duties.
Those proposals remain under public consultation at the Executive Secretariat of the Foreign Trade Chamber, with no date set for a decision by Gecex. Sindiveg argues that maintaining zero tariffs on formulated products that are also manufactured in Brazil weakens the protection afforded to domestic production and discourages the use of installed industrial capacity.
The tariff campaign has, however, triggered a rift within the industry itself. Generic pesticide companies Tecnomyl and Alta announced on Friday that they would leave Sindiveg after the union submitted its requests for duties of up to 35% on imported formulations, particularly from China and India.
Tecnomyl Brasil said it would not renew its membership for 2027, citing disagreement with measures that it believes could make crop protection products more expensive, restrict competition and reduce farmers’ supply options. The company also said it had not been consulted or involved in the discussions leading to the tariff requests, despite being a Sindiveg member.
The dispute could extend to other industry organizations. Market sources said generic pesticide company CHDS is considering leaving CropLife Brasil, which represents multinational agricultural input companies and supported other tariff requests submitted by Abifina.
AgriConnection, which is not affiliated with the organizations involved, also opposed the proposed increases, arguing that tariffs of up to 35% could limit competition, reduce supply alternatives and add pressure to farm production costs.
Aenda has questioned whether higher tariffs would strengthen domestic manufacturing, noting that previous increases involving glyphosate, acephate and 2,4-D did not necessarily lead to greater Brazilian production. The association has instead called for structural measures, including improved financing conditions and lower manufacturing costs.
It has also submitted a separate request to reduce import duties from 7.2% to zero on certain formulated insecticides sold in packages of up to 7.5 kilograms, aligning their tax treatment with that of larger packages, which are already exempt. That proposal is also scheduled for consideration on Tuesday.
The debate highlights the challenge of reconciling industrial policy with the cost and competitiveness of Brazilian agriculture. While manufacturers seek greater protection against imported formulations, farmers and some industry players warn that higher tariffs could raise input costs without necessarily expanding domestic production. Tuesday’s deliberations will determine the next stage of a dispute that has already revealed significant divisions across the crop protection sector.